Vietnamâ€™s Temporary Release of Priest Goes against Trend
Government granting leave to Father Ly is said to be tightening control overall.
DUBLIN, March 30 MPBS24/7 REPORT From(CDN) â€” Vietnamese officials have in recent months tightened control over those they regard as dissidents, and the temporary release of Catholic priest Thadeus Nguyen van Ly on March 15 was a rare exception, according to Amnesty International (AI).
Officials on March 15 released Ly, now 63, from prison for one year so that he could receive medical treatment.
An outspoken advocate for religious freedom, Ly was sentenced to eight years in prison in March 2007 for â€śspreading propagandaâ€ť against the state. He had previously received 10- and 15-year sentences on similar charges.
â€śThe release of Father Ly appears to be a one-off, related to his health,â€ť Brittis Edman, Asia researcher for AI, told Compass by phone.
Human rights lawyer Le Thi Cong Nhan was released on March 6 after serving a three years in prison. Officials have sentenced 16 other â€śperceived dissidentsâ€ť since last September.
â€śThose 16 are people whose names are in the public domain,â€ť Edman added. â€śThere are probably others weâ€™re not aware of.â€ť
Edman confirmed that Ly was recently diagnosed with a brain tumor, although few details are available on the prognosis or the availability of treatment. Fellow priests told the Union of Catholic Asian News (UCAN) that Ly had suffered three strokes in May, September and November of last year, partially paralyzing his right arm and leg and making it difficult for him to walk, write or feed himself.
Following urgent requests from diocesan priests and family members, officials on March 14 granted Ly one yearâ€™s reprieve from his jail sentence. On March 15 they transported him by ambulance from Ba Sao prison camp in northern Ha Nam province to a home for retired priests in Hue, central Vietnam.
Under pressure from international advocacy groups including AI, the government may have granted Lyâ€™s release to ward off potential embarrassment should he die in prison, Edman said.
â€śHeâ€™s a very public figure, and the Vietnamese government is not comfortable with being criticized.â€ť
Religious Rights Campaigner
Ly was first jailed for one year in 1977 when he distributed a Church statement decrying the arrest of Buddhist monks and the treatment of Catholics in Vietnam, according to an AI report.
This was followed in December 1983 by a 10-year sentence served from the time of his arrest in May 1983 until his early release in July 1992. Prior to his arrest, Ly wrote a seven-point document urging officials to cease harassing Christians and announced that he was willing to be martyred for his faith.
In November 1994 Ly issued a â€śTen Point Statement on the State of the Catholic Church in the Hue Diocese,â€ť criticizing the lack of adequate training for would-be priests, the stateâ€™s interference in church teachings and its appropriation of church property.
He also became an advisory board member of the U.S.-based Committee for Religious Freedom in Vietnam (CRFV), according to AI.
In 1999, authorities objected when Ly coordinated relief projects for flood victims in partnership with CRFV. In November 2000, while U.S. President Bill Clinton and a CRFV delegation were in Vietnam, Ly reissued his ten-point statement and later made further appeals for religious freedom.
The United States Commission on International Religious Freedom in February 2001 invited Ly to address a hearing on Vietnam. Though unable to attend, Ly submitted written testimony stating that the Vietnamese government had â€śstripped all churches of their independence and freedomâ€ť and urging that the U.S. Congress not ratify a long-negotiated U.S.-Vietnam Bilateral Trade Agreement.
State-owned media then accused Ly of inviting â€śforeign hostile forces to intervene in Vietnamâ€™s internal affairsâ€ť and inciting Catholic followers against the state.
Officials in May 2001 seized Ly during a church service and sentenced him to 15 years in prison for allegedly spreading anti-government propaganda. He was released under house arrest in February 2005 but arrested again in February 2007 and sentenced to eight years for organizing a pro-democracy event.
When the government released over 5,000 prisoners to mark Vietnamâ€™s National Day last Sept. 2, Ly was omitted from the list despite vigorous international campaigns for his release. In a state media report quoted by UCAN, Vice Minister of Public Security Le The Tiem declared that the priest was â€śstill in good enough health to serve his sentence.â€ť