Family Refutes Police Claims in Death of Christian in India
Bible teacher in Rajasthan state, 20, faced opposition from Hindu nationalists.
NEW DELHI, August 25 MPBS24/7 REPORT From(CDN) â€” The family of a 20-year-old Christian found dead last week in the northern state of Rajasthan suspects he was killed by Hindu nationalists, though police claim he died of cardiac arrest.
Narayan Lal, a farmer from Hameerpura Patar village in Arnod sub-district of Rajasthanâ€™s Pratapgarh district, was found dead the evening of Aug. 17 near a forest where he had gone to tend his goats.
Lal was a volunteer teacher in a 10-day Vacation Bible School organized by indigenous Christian organization Light of the World Service Society (Jagat Jyoti Seva Sansthan) in his village area in May, and a relative who requested anonymity told Compass that some villagers did not approve of the young man â€śspreading Christianity.â€ť
â€śIt seems his throat was strangulated,â€ť the relative said. â€śI do not know who did it, but I am sure he was murdered. His family was facing opposition for their Christian work, particularly by some residents of Nadikhera village [near Hameerpura Patar].â€ť
A post-mortem report suggested otherwise, police said.
â€śThe body of Narayan Lal, son of Tola Ram Meena, was found under a tree,â€ť Superintendent of Police of Pratapgarh district Prem Prakash Tak told Compass. â€śThere was some froth formation in his mouth, but no injuries or bruises. The post-mortem was conducted by three doctors, and they suggest that he died of cardio-respiratory failure.â€ť
He added that police had not heard that the family suspected murder. The relative said, however, that Lalâ€™s father told police that his son was seemingly killed by some people from Nadikhera village who had been opposing him and his family. Salamgarh Police Inspector Govardhan Ram Chowdhary was unavailable for comment.
Lalâ€™s relative contested the police version, saying Lal was â€śabsolutely healthyâ€ť with â€śno sign of any ailment.â€ť
â€śI cannot believe that he died of heart failure â€“ he was very young,â€ť he said. â€śHis shoes were lying near his body, and a piece of cloth was kept on his hands. It seemed that the cloth was used to tie his hands.â€ť
The relative asked why police did not inform the family of their autopsy reportâ€™s indication of cardiac arrest.
â€śWe would have taken the body to a private hospital for confirmation,â€ť he said.
The death was reported to Salamgarh police at 10 p.m. on Aug. 17 under Section 174 of the Criminal Procedure Code for â€śdeath under suspicious circumstances.â€ť The autopsy was performed on Aug. 18, after which the body was handed over to the family for cremation.
Police Superintendent Tak acknowledged that Lalâ€™s father, an elder in the village church, had been arrested in July 2008 on charges of desecrating an idol of a Hindu deity in the village. He was released after police failed to find evidence against him.
â€śHe [Lalâ€™s father] was falsely accused by those who did not like his missionary work,â€ť the deceasedâ€™s relative said. â€śIt was a plot to oppose his work.â€ť
Christian persecution is not new to Rajasthan state, where Christian conversion is a sensitive issue.
The Rajasthan government passed an anti-conversion law in the state assembly in April 2006, when the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) was in power. The bill is still awaiting the governorâ€™s assent.
The BJP led the government of Rajasthan from March 1990 to November 1998, and again from December 2003 to December 2008, when the Left-of-Center Congress Party won the election.
The incidence of Christian persecution is said to have decreased since the BJPâ€™s defeat in the 2008 state election, with the exception of sporadic incidents.
About 30 suspected Hindu extremists assaulted two Christian workers from Gospel for Asia and chased them into the jungle near Rajasthanâ€™s Banswara city on Sept. 4, 2009. (See â€śRecent Incidents of Persecution,â€ť Sept. 29, 2009.)
On March 21, 2009, Hindu nationalists from the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP or World Hindu Council) attacked Bible students and staff members of the Believers Church and demanded 10,000 rupees (US$193) from them in Udaipur city. (See â€śRecent Incidents of Persecution,â€ť March 31, 2009.)
On April 29, 2007, at least 14 Hindu extremists in Jaipur, Rajasthan attacked Pastor Walter Masih with sticks and rods as television cameras recorded the scene, leaving him bleeding profusely. The then-Hindu nationalist government in the state declined to prosecute the more serious charges against the assailants.
BJP leaders harassed leaders of the Emmanuel Mission International (EMI), based in Kota city, in 2006, leading to the arrest of the Christians and the freezing of EMI bank accounts.